FAQ: Windows Media vs ShoutCast
The biggest and most important difference is they are totally different audio streaming formats. What do we mean? Well, Shoutcast employs formats such as MP3/MP3PRO and is the most popular form of broadcast. WMA on the other hand is strictly Windows Media based. Hence the name Windows Media Audio. Honestly at the moment most radio stations go for ShoutCast. The sound is great and listeners can use almost any player. Also mp3PRO is simply fantastic at low bitrates when using ShoutCast. Some stations do provide a Windows Media stream as well as an alternative stream for their listeners.

Windows Media Server   ShoutCast Server
-Supports Windows Media Audio   -Supports mp3, mp3PRO, aac+
     
-Needs a Windows Media Encoder on your side like the DRS 2006 Internet Broadcaster or the Windows Media Encoder
  -Needs a mp3 or mp3PRO Encoder on your side like the the DRS 2006 Internet Broadcaster or Winamp together with the ShoutCast DSP Plugin
     
-uses "Publishing Points" to identify the stream   -uses "Ports" to identify the stream
     

-Link to stream looks like:
http://server/PublishingPoint or
mms://server/PublishingPoint

  -Link to stream looks like:
http://server:Port/listen.pls
     
-Your listeners use the Windows Media Player to listen. Winamp will not work.   -Your listeners use Winamp or any other mp3 Player to listen. Even the new Windows Media Player 9 can connect to ShoutCast streams.
     
-You can't set any server options yourself.   -The DRS 2006 Radio Streamer offers a user interface which you can use to set several server options yourself.
     
-No automatic listing anywhere   -Your stream can be automatically listed on ShoutCast.com
     
-WMA does not sound that good at low bitrates   -mp3PRO sounds good at low bitrates, but listeners need a plugin for mp3PRO
     
-WMA sounds quite good at medium bitrates like 64 kbps   -plain mp3 sounds good at high bitrates
     
-Supports "PUSH" and "PULL" technology. You push the stream to us or we pull it from your PC. When pulling you need a steady IP.   -only supports "PUSH" technology. You push the stream to us.
     
-Supports multiple bitrates within a single stream.   -Does not support multiple bitrates.
     
-Great if you want to build embedded players on your website   -Embedding in a website it not that handy, but also possible
     
-No intro or backup files supported   -Server allows to use intro and backup files


Copyright © 1999-2008 by